On July 6, 1868, 10 brethren resigned their memberships in Lodge 62 in order to form a new Lodge in the city of Reading to be called St. John's Lodge. This new Lodge was not to be formed without controversy, however, over the need for another Masonic Lodge in Reading. After a thorough investigation by The Grand Lodge of Pennsylvania, and the Grand Master himself visiting Reading to hear the arguments for and against the formation of a new Lodge, a charter was granted to the St. John's Lodge No. 435 on March 1, 1869.
At a special meeting that day, the Right Worshipful Grand Master, Richard Vaux, accompanied by the Grand Lodge Officers Constituted St. John's Lodge, with Bro. Frederick S. Boas installed as Worshipful Master; John McKnight, Senior Warden; Edward H Shearer, Junior Warden; Edward P. Boas, Treasurer; William G. McGowan, Secretary. At the first stated meeting of St. John's Lodge, the following appointments were made; Brothers Thomas F. Hemmich, Senior Deacon, Henry M. Keim, Junior Deacon, Reese W. Frescoln, Senior Mastor of Ceremonies, Christopher Loeser, Junior Master of Ceremonies, and Albert A. Simon, Pursuivant. These ten men being the same that resigned from Lodge 62 almost a year earlier.
At the stated meeting of August 6, 1869, the first by-laws were adopted.
Over the years St. John's Lodge has met at four locations in the Reading area.
Originally meeting at the American House on the South West corner of 4th and Penn Streets. Meetings were held on the upper floor of this building until a new Lodge meeting place was obtained on the 3rd floor of City Hall located at 5th and Franklin Streets in 1873.